MB struggled in the first half to score against a strong Middletown squad and dug themselves into a hole at the half, with Middletown leading 25-15 at the half. Although they came out flat to start the 2nd half, the Quakers eventually caught some momentum after Christian Chase hit a three pointer to bring the game within reach. With 55 seconds left in the game, MB took the lead 41-39. Middletown came right back and scored a layup with 10 seconds left in regulation. MB had a chance to go ahead with 3 seconds left, but missed the front end of the 1 and 1, eventually sending the game into overtime. It was all Quakers in OT. MB scored 7 points and held Middletown scoreless with a 48 to 41 win.